Review · USA

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake

★ 5.0 · 13 reviews 45 minutes (approx.) From $20 Operated by Deer Run Winery · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

The best part of this Conesus Lake tasting is its small, homey feel. At Deer Run Winery, you sit down with four three-ounce pours rather than hurry through a crowded counter. Candi, Sam, Grace, and Hailey have each made the tasting a friendly, personal stop for visitors.

I like the generous amount of wine for the price, and I like the mix of cheese and chocolate pairings. The setting is close to Conesus Lake, and the maximum group size of six keeps the experience calm. The main drawback is that the chocolate samples can feel modest for some people, and the winery does not offer a lake view.

Key points to know

  • Four three-ounce pours: You receive a total of 12 ounces of wine, paired with cheese or chocolate.
  • A small winery setting: Deer Run feels intimate and informal rather than polished like a large commercial tasting room.
  • Two sweet wines: Pebble Beach Blush and Max Black suit visitors who prefer fruit-forward, sweet styles.
  • Friendly personal service: Candi, Sam, Grace, and Hailey are named as hosts who help make the tasting easy and social.
  • Lunch is separate: You can stay for food at the Tankroom Café, but lunch is not part of the $20 tasting.
  • Book ahead: The experience is often reserved about 14 days in advance, and the group limit is six people.

Four wines, four small food pairings

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - Four wines, four small food pairings

This is a seated tasting built around four of Deer Run Winery’s best-selling wines. You receive four three-ounce pours, each matched with either cheese or chocolate. At $20 per person, that works out to about $5 for each wine and pairing, with a full 12 ounces of wine included.

The tasting is simple. You sit down, receive the flight, and use the pairing sheet to follow the wines and their flavor notes. It is not a formal wine class, and you should not expect a long lecture about winemaking. The appeal is the relaxed pace and the chance to compare four different styles in one sitting.

Two wines are paired with cheese:

  • Conesus White: A semi-dry white with grape-forward notes and a gold medal award.
  • Runway Red: A smooth red blend with berry and black pepper notes, also a gold medal winner and recognized as best in category.

The other two wines are paired with chocolate:

  • Pebble Beach Blush: A sweet blend with peach and melon notes, awarded double gold.
  • Max Black: Deer Run’s best-selling sweet red blend, with grape jelly notes and a gold medal award.

This lineup gives you a useful range without making the tasting feel heavy. The Conesus White should appeal to anyone who likes a little sweetness in a white wine. Runway Red offers the most classic red-wine profile, while Pebble Beach Blush and Max Black are designed for people who enjoy sweeter, fruit-led pours.

If you usually avoid sweet wine, you may prefer the two cheese pairings. One tasting attendee enjoyed three of the four wines but did not care for the sweet style. That is not a flaw in the flight so much as a useful warning: half the tasting leans sweet.

More Wine and Chocolate Tours in the USA

What the cheese and chocolate add

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - What the cheese and chocolate add

The food samples are there to show how the wines behave with something to eat. The cheese pairings help soften and balance the wine, while the chocolate pairings bring out the fruit and sweetness in the final two pours.

The exact cheese selection can vary, but one visit included small bowls of cheese curds. The chocolate samples included a piece of Lindt chocolate and a miniature peanut butter cup. You should think of these as tasting portions, not a dessert plate or a cheese board.

That distinction matters when judging the price. At $20, the value comes mainly from the quantity of wine and the chance to sample four bottles. If you expect a generous serving of cheese and chocolate, you may find the food side a little thin. One person specifically felt the chocolate pairing was expensive for its size.

I would plan to eat before or after the tasting if you need a full meal. The Tankroom Café serves lunch at the winery, but lunch costs extra and is not included in the experience.

A tasting room with a personal feel

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - A tasting room with a personal feel

Deer Run Winery is smaller than the large tasting rooms found along major wine routes. That can be a plus if you prefer a quiet table and direct attention. It can also mean the experience feels less like an event.

One couple found the room so quiet on a fall Friday that they were left to sip and eat with little activity around them. They liked the calm, but anyone hoping for a lively group tasting should set expectations accordingly.

The small scale also gives the staff room to talk with you. Candi has been praised for making people comfortable and keeping water refreshed while they waited before driving. Sam was described as enthusiastic during the tasting, while Grace took time to explain the grapes used in several wines. Hailey also helped make a solo tasting feel social and easy.

Staffing can change, so you may not meet a particular person. Still, the pattern is clear: this is a place where personal service matters more than a slick presentation.

The setting is near Conesus Lake, but it is not a lake-view stop. You can add it to a day around the lake, yet you should not book the tasting expecting scenery from the table.

Following the tasting from white to red

The first pour, Conesus White, gives you a gentle start. Its semi-dry character and grape notes make it approachable, especially if you are new to wine tasting or prefer whites that are not sharply dry. The cheese gives you something savory to compare against the wine’s fruit.

Next comes Runway Red. The berry and black pepper notes offer a clear contrast to the white. Its smooth style should make it the safest choice for a mixed group, especially when some people drink red wine regularly and others do not.

Pebble Beach Blush shifts the flight toward sweetness. Peach and melon notes make this a fruit-forward choice, and the chocolate pairing reinforces that dessert-like character. If you enjoy sweet rosé or sweet blends, this may be one of your favorites. If you prefer crisp, dry wines, it may be the least appealing pour.

Max Black finishes the flight with the fullest sweet profile. Its grape jelly notes are direct and easy to understand, and it is Deer Run’s best seller. The name has a story connected to the wine, and one visitor bought a bottle after hearing it.

The order makes sense: lighter white first, red blend next, then the sweeter blush and red. You can take notes on the provided pairing sheet, compare your reactions, and decide which bottle is worth taking home.

How the $20 price works for you

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - How the $20 price works for you

The price is one of the strongest features of this experience. For $20, you receive four three-ounce pours. Many wine tastings offer smaller samples, so the 12-ounce total gives you enough wine to form a real opinion about each bottle.

The value is best if you enjoy tasting several styles rather than ordering a single glass. It is also useful for couples or friends who want to choose a bottle together before buying. Several people have taken home wine after the tasting, including Max Black and red blends.

The calculation changes if you focus mainly on the food. The cheese and chocolate portions are samples, not a substantial snack. If you regard the wine as the main purchase, the price is strong. If you are paying mostly for a cheese-and-chocolate spread, you may want more.

You should also remember that the tasting price does not include lunch. The Tankroom Café gives you a reason to stay longer, and the food has received praise, but you need a separate budget for it.

Why the six-person limit matters

The experience allows a maximum of six people. That is a useful limit for a tasting because you can hear the server, ask questions, and keep the pace comfortable.

For a solo visitor, the setting can still work well. Hailey helped one solo guest enjoy the flight as a social experience before moving to the café for lunch. For couples, the format makes an easy date stop. Four friends can share reactions without taking over the room.

The small capacity also means you should not wait until the last minute if your schedule is fixed. The tasting is booked, on average, about 14 days ahead. A mobile ticket makes the reservation easy to carry on your phone, and confirmation is provided when you book.

The winery welcomes service animals, and most people can take part. No special fitness is needed because the activity is a seated tasting.

Adding lunch at the Tankroom Café

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - Adding lunch at the Tankroom Café

Lunch is not part of the tasting, but staying for a meal can turn a 45-minute stop into a longer outing. The café has received praise for its food, including a burger and chips and other meals described as both enjoyable and healthy.

The timing works well if you do not want to drive immediately after the wine. You can eat, drink water, and take your time before leaving. One server even refilled water while a couple waited to sober up.

Do not treat lunch as guaranteed within the tasting price. It is an optional extra, and the experience ends back at the winery’s meeting point. If you plan to eat, check the café’s availability when arranging your visit.

Planning your Conesus Lake stop

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - Planning your Conesus Lake stop

The meeting point is Deer Run Winery, at 3772 W Lake Road, Geneseo, New York 14454. The activity begins and ends there. Since there is no transportation included, you need to arrange your own way to the winery.

The tasting lasts about 45 minutes. That is long enough to sample the four wines without taking up an entire day. You can pair it with other Conesus Lake plans, but allow extra time if you intend to eat lunch or browse bottles afterward.

You should have a plan for getting home safely. Four three-ounce pours add up to a substantial amount of wine, even though the tasting is short. A designated driver is the sensible choice, and ordering food and water afterward can help you slow down before leaving.

The cancellation policy is friendly but firm. You receive a full refund if you cancel at least 24 hours before the start time. Cancellations or changes made within 24 hours are not refunded or accepted.

Who will enjoy this wine tasting most

Shared Wine, Chocolate and Cheese Tasting in Conesus Lake - Who will enjoy this wine tasting most

I would choose this experience for:

  • Couples looking for a relaxed date stop
  • Small groups who prefer personal service
  • People who enjoy sweet or fruit-forward wines
  • First-time wine tasters who want clear, approachable styles
  • Solo visitors who like a quiet tasting and the option of lunch afterward
  • Wine shoppers who want to sample bottles before buying

I would be more cautious if you want a grand tasting room, sweeping lake views, large food portions, or a strong focus on dry wines. The room is small, the food samples are limited, and two of the four pours are sweet.

The experience also suits people who value conversation over ceremony. You may sit with other groups rather than receive a private table. One couple shared a table with two other couples and enjoyed the social side, but that arrangement will not suit someone seeking complete privacy.

Should you book the Deer Run tasting?

Book it if you want a good-value four-wine flight in a small winery, especially if cheese, chocolate, and sweet wines appeal to you. The 12 ounces of wine for $20 is generous, and the staff’s friendly approach is the strongest part of the visit.

Skip it if you expect a full meal, a scenic lake view, or a polished large-scale wine-tour production. The chocolate samples may feel small, and the quiet room can seem underwhelming if you want a busy afternoon out.

My practical choice would be to reserve ahead, arrive with a safe ride plan, and add lunch if the café is open. Give yourself time to compare the wines, then consider buying a bottle of the style you liked best. This is a modest, low-key tasting, but it offers solid value and a genuine sense of place near Conesus Lake.

FAQ

How much does the wine, chocolate, and cheese tasting cost?

The tasting costs $20 per person.

How long does the experience last?

The tasting lasts approximately 45 minutes.

How many wines are included?

Four wines are included.

How much wine do I receive?

You receive four three-ounce pours, for a total of 12 ounces of wine.

What wines are served?

The tasting includes Conesus White, Runway Red, Pebble Beach Blush, and Max Black.

What food is paired with the wine?

Two wines are paired with cheese, and two wines are paired with chocolate.

Is lunch included?

No. Lunch is not included, though food is available separately at the Tankroom Café.

Where does the tasting take place?

The tasting begins and ends at Deer Run Winery, 3772 W Lake Road, Geneseo, New York 14454.

How many people can join the tasting?

The activity has a maximum of six people.

Can I cancel for a full refund?

Yes. You can cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Cancellations within 24 hours are not refunded.

Similar chocolate experiences

More USA Chocolate Tours to compare.

Every USA chocolate tour →
Lahaina: Maui Ku’ia Estate Guided Cacao Farm Tour and Tasting
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 1,103 reviews· from $99

Lahaina: Maui Ku’ia Estate Guided Cacao Farm Tour and Tasting

Read our review →
Princeville Botanical Gardens Tour and Chocolate Tasting Ticket
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 774 reviews· from $126

Princeville Botanical Gardens Tour and Chocolate Tasting Ticket

Read our review →
Kauai Chocolate Farm Tasting Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 666 reviews· from $145

Kauai Chocolate Farm Tasting Tour

Read our review →
Award Winning Farm Tour: Coffee, Chocolate and Unique Gifts
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 484 reviews· from $50

Award Winning Farm Tour: Coffee, Chocolate and Unique Gifts

Read our review →
Nashville’s Goo Goo Chocolate Tasting & Candy Making Class
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 247 reviews· from $55

Nashville’s Goo Goo Chocolate Tasting & Candy Making Class

Read our review →
Orlando: Factory Adventure Tour in Chocolate Kingdom
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 240 reviews· from $24

Orlando: Factory Adventure Tour in Chocolate Kingdom

Read our review →
Volcano, Chocolate and Waterfalls of the Big Island
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 238 reviews· from $308

Volcano, Chocolate and Waterfalls of the Big Island

Read our review →
Seattle Chocolate Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 216 reviews· from $85

Seattle Chocolate Tour

Read our review →
Scroll to Top

Pick your kind of chocolate

Taste it, make it, or go and find where it grows.